Trader Joe’s Mandarin Orange Chicken is a perennial favorite of everyone’s favorite odd little supermarket. Freezers across the country are stocked with bags of this weekday dinner delight and it has been a lifesaver in terms of getting everyone satisfactorily fed in my household as well.
However, we seem to be living in the age of meatless alternatives. If you like hamburgers you can default to the old standbys like Boca or Morningstar Farms, but you are more likely to choose a Beyond Burger or Impossible Burger. Heck, you can even get moderately priced meatless fair from the ever quirky Aldi.
You can also get a bag of meatless orange chicken from Aldi. Or is it orange not-quite-so-chicken? I digress.
Naturally, I wanted to compare Aldi’s offering with that of the old standby Trader Joe’s:
An initial visual inspection reveals the primary difference between the two products. The Aldi alternative is much more like chicken nuggets with sauce while the Trader Joe’s offering is more akin to Chinese takeout. If you desire the craggy and crunchy thrill of deep fried chicken pieces than Trader Joe’s will win every time. You can see the difference:
In truth, that is the primary difference. Let’s be honest for a moment. The presence of actual chicken versus a textured vegetable protein is almost a non-factor because I do not know of anyone who eats frozen orange chicken because of the meat. This is a show about crunchy fried bits and orange sauce. Unless you run across a stray piece of cartilage there is nothing that you remember about the chicken. I posit that you could sell people pieces of deep fried batter in orange sauce, minus any actual protein, and it would sell quite well.
Aside from the texture difference of the chicken pieces there is a slight difference in the taste of the orange sauce. The Aldi version is slightly thinner and sweeter. The Trader Joe’s version is thicker and has a vinegar bite. Which do you prefer? That would be personal as I know people who prefer thin red sweet and sour over thicker and more vinegary sweet and sour.
The real question I have is why Aldi could not have made a meatless orange chicken that duplicated the craggy fried goodness of the Trader Joe’s Mandarin Orange Chicken. It would seem to me that random and misshapen bits of protein covered in battered and deep fried would be an easier problem to solve versus the analogue of a breast meat nugget. Just saying.